A Safe Space to Be Loud: Beartooth Lifts Up New York’s Hammerstein Ballroom

Beartooth, live at Hammerstein Ballroom on November 12, 2026.

Every so often a show comes along that makes me step back and appreciate the power of music to bring people together and build a community. Everyone deserves a safe space to be loud. This year, even the guy on stage, Caleb Shomo, needed the crowd to catch him. And they did, lifting him higher than ever before.

Beartooth spent the early part of 2026 riding high on an opening slot for Bad Omens’ North American arena run alongside PRESIDENT, one of the biggest metal tours of the year. Then in May, less than a week after the band announced the Pure Ecstasy World Tour, Caleb publicly came out to fans.

Caleb risked it all with a new album due in August and a North American headline tour kicking off in November. And the risk, the bravery, was worth it. That brings us to a rainy Manhattan evening at Hammerstein Ballroom, Beartooth’s second stop of the tour. Joining the band on tour were Don Broco, Magnolia Park and Windwaker.

WINDWAKER

Australian metalcore outfit Windwaker opened the evening at Hammerstein. About a year had passed since I last saw them, and I love watching a band mature in both sound and stage presence. Windwaker checks both boxes. This time around, the band looked much more comfortable in their opening slot and even kicked off an early wall of death. Hammerstein’s wide stage did leave the members a bit spread out, though. Frontman Liam Guinane made full use of the space, but I feel like pulling in the flanks a bit would have made their energy more of a punch.

MAGNOLIA PARK

I’d been waiting a while to catch Florida’s Magnolia Park live, and they lived up to the hype. They leveled up the energy in what was now a full room. Every member of the band was on the move across the broad stage, constantly switching sides on stage. Something that perhaps the Windwaker set needed.

At one point, guitarist Tristan Torres left the stage and had the crowd form a massive circle pit around him, then crowd surfed his way back to the stage without missing a note. Click through to the end of their gallery to see it all take place! Before the end of their set, they called on all the women in the crowd to start a queen pit. I love moments like these, where fans who might be a bit more reserved get to come forward and be free.

DON BROCO

After Magnolia Park’s set, I couldn’t imagine another opener taking the room’s energy and multiplying it. Don Broco is one of those bands that bring an infectious energy, not that tonight’s crowd needed any help. Crowd surfers poured over the barricade like rain into storm drains outside. Guitarist Simon Delaney spent the entire set skipping in huge circles around the stage, pausing only for high kicks that could rival the Rockettes a few blocks uptown. Frontman Rob Damiani was his own vibe in orange-tinted shades and some sort of bedazzled camo pants. Yes, I said bedazzled. Streaming Don Broco’s 2026 album Nightmare Tripping only gets you so far. They are a must-add to your concert wishlist for 2027.

BEARTOOTH

As I sit down to write this review and think back on Beartooth’s set, I still get chills. Every so often a show resonates on so many levels with so many people in the room. You feel it down to your core, and from the band to the back of the room, everyone feels it. It’s almost euphoric.

I caught Beartooth on their run with Bad Omens earlier this year, and this version of Caleb was re-energized. With a burden off his shoulders, he seemed to stand taller, wearing a genuine smile that could not be faked. He’s now living as the truest version of himself, and that positive energy translated directly into the band’s performance.

After my three songs in the photo pit, I stood among the sea of fans in GA, and you could literally feel the floor shake as fans danced and moshed through the 17-song set. After “In Between,” Caleb had his own Freddie Mercury moment. He led the crowd in a call and response with no mic, filling Hammerstein’s vaulted ceiling with his own “Woah-oah-oh-ohhhh-oh-oh,” and the crowd matched every note.

For the the high point of the evening came between songs, when Caleb paused to share this message with the crowd:

“All because of this fucking music, ok. This music has been the only place that I have ever felt like I could understand things about myself that I didn’t want to understand. By writing these songs alone in a fucking room. By asking questions that I never wanted to ask. By being somebody I was always afraid to fucking be. But I can tell you, I can tell you, holy shit it has been so fucking worth it! Because now I get to stand here in front of you and I get to show you fucking all of me. And that’s all I’ve ever wanted, is for you to understand how powerful music can fucking be. So just let yourself go.”

On the train ride home, I could finally process the evening. Imagine accepting your true self and asking your fans to accept that version of you too. Somewhere along the way you might lose a few fans, but you gain so many more. Caleb took the biggest risk of his career this year, and the people who love this band and everything it stands for showed up for him. Thousands of fans at Hammerstein Ballroom had a safe space to be loud, and so did the guy on stage.

BEARTOOTH | WEBSITE | INSTAGRAM | FACEBOOK | YOUTUBE


Didn’t see yourself in the galleries above? Check out our bonus gallery below for more crowd-surfing and mosh pit chaos! If you spot yourself, we want to hear from you! Let us know in the comments!



BEARTOOTH Setlist

Hammerstein Ballroom, New York, New York (11/12/2026)

  • Pure Ecstasy

  • Bullshit

  • Beaten in Lips

  • Hated

  • In Between

  • Beautiful Again

  • Bad Listener

  • Disease

  • Free

  • Sunshine!

  • The Last Riff

  • The Past Is Dead

  • Drum Solo

  • Stadiums

  • Eyes Closed

  • Riptide

  • The Lines

Encore

  • Might Love Myself


Check out more from our contributor:

RYAN REID | WEBSITE | INSTAGRAM | FACEBOOK

Ryan Reid

Covering stages across Connecticut and NYC, Ryan brings a bold, story-driven perspective to live music photography, capturing everything from massive productions to intimate sets. Ryan is the founder and editor-in-chief of RØKKR Press.

https://www.ryanreidphotography.com
Previous
Previous

It’s a Pop Punk Christmas! Bayside Release “Best Christmas Yet”

Next
Next

This Is Lorelei Delivers Nothing But Love at Greenpoint’s Warsaw