Crowd Surfing and Generational Divides: Catch Your Breath in NYC

Last Friday, November 13th, Catch Your Breath stopped at NYC’s Irving Plaza for another show of the Not Broken Enough World Tour with support from Colorblind, Arankai, and TX2, and it was a wild ride from start to finish. I witnessed a never-ending sea of crowd surfers and a permanent mosh pit throughout the night. The ages of the crowd ranged from 6 to 60, not surprising with such a varied lineup. What I was not expecting, however, was to leave with such an interesting case study of generational divides within the scene.

COLORBLIND

Due to subway issues, I arrived late, right as the first band of the lineup, Colorblind, opened their set with “Ghost”. The crowd could be heard singing from the first floor of the venue, and as I went up the stairs to the showroom, I noticed how packed the pit was. It was a rare sight and the loudest singing I’ve ever heard for the first song of the first band of a lineup of four.  This high intensity continued to build up, with crowd surfers popping up immediately after the first song.

Colorblind’s lead singer, Travis Moseley, pointed out his surprise: “Holy shit New York, you guys really know how to go hard. Let’s keep this going” — and the crowd sure did. For the rest of the night, every single song had anywhere from 2 to 10 surfers; a nightmare for venue security posted in front of the pit to catch them, but a dream for energetic concert goers looking to blow steam on a Friday night.

Colorblind’s set was a masterful display of a polished performance that set the standards high for the rest of the night. Moseley’s vocal versatility and ability to switch between clean, angelic-like melodic vocals and deep, guttural screams was otherworldly. When hearing it in person, it’s sometimes hard to believe both sounds come from the same person.

The band departed the stage after the last song of their set to a roaring applause, but not before telling the crowd they would be at the merch table after their set. “We won’t leave until we meet every single one of you,” Moseley expressed. A sentiment that was well taken advantage of by fans that were there to see primarily Colorblind, as they crowded the first floor and overflowed the merch lines during the second act.

ARANKAI

Have you ever wondered what it would be like if a volcano could sing? Me neither, but after Friday’s performance, I feel like Oscar Porter — lead singer and founder of alternative metal project Arankai — took a stab at answering the question nobody thought to ask before. Porter’s vocals rattled the floors and shook us all to our cores from the moment he stepped on stage with opening track “I Hope It Hurts” from Arankai’s latest album, The Shape of Blue.

The deep, booming sound of Porter’s voice was startling, especially as a person who had never been exposed to Arankai’s music before. I was floored by the fullness and rotundness of the tone in his clean vocals, which came in strong contrast to his creaky, raspy fry screams. Porter’s stage presence was intense; from full-body long-haired head banging to high and heavy steps, fee-fi-fo-fo-ing his way across the floor. The rumble of it all truly incited in me the primal astonishment that I assume is the feeling of being in the presence of an active volcano.

Arankai fans were all for it, chanting along to “Letdown” with such vigor, it almost rivaled that of Porter’s voice — something Porter himself noticed, apparent by the way his face contorted almost in disgust at the sheer volume from his fans during the chorus. However, the audience truly erupted during Arankai’s cover of Switchfoot’s “Meant to Live”. The track was a more-than-decent rendering of the original and an absolute crowd pleaser, especially amongst the older members of the crowd, some of which were standing idly during his set up to this point. It was very interesting to watch as the individuals who were laid back suddenly bursted out effervescently in song, while the younger crowd members toned down and watched curiously, like someone left out of an inside joke.

Lucky for them, this moment of exclusion was short-lived, and the younger fans ramped up the energy back up again after the next song: “Helter Skelter”, a trap-inspired metal track that opens with a spooky slowed down beat and a bouncy rap verse — a modern gender-bending formula that explains the viral success of Arankai on social media platforms.

TX2

Following up was another viral social media sensation, TX2. Gaining notoriety through the controversial presentation and overly animated demeanor of lead singer Timothy Evan Thomas, TX2 really ran with the phrase “I am cringe but I am free.” The four piece band took over the stage in a frenzy, delivering one of the most energetic and over-the-top performances I have ever seen on a rock stage. Starting with a hellacious and theatrical drum solo by Ethan Church, and lasting through their set from the part of frontman Thomas, who I did not see stand still for more than one second. A marvel to observe as an audience member, and an absolute nightmare to photograph.

Something I learned at this show is that TX2 is all about high theatrics and impactful aesthetics. Just three songs into their set during “Vendetta”, both the lead singer and the guitarist jumped into the crowd and played the final chorus in the center of a massive circle pit. Their outfits were glaringly punk with a dash of provocation: think cropped leather jackets, shirts off, studs, chains, and fishnets. Their stage presence was just as loud as their outfits, with occasional group choreography and ample mid-song interactions between band members. Honestly, TX2 really knows how to put on a show.

During their set, I noticed (as expected) that the majority of their fans skewed younger. While shooting the first three songs in the photo pit, a fan at barricade held up a sign that said “this is my first concert”, as I assume was the same case for many others that night. While younger fans were making first-show memories, the older crowd filled up the hallways on the first floor. Many took TX2’s set as their bathroom and bar break, and inescapably, as a debrief session. I ran into some friends who were in the pit and are avid concert goers, and I caught them in the middle of a conversation about the night so far. They were talking about a girl who had gotten hurt by a crowd surfer, and aired some grievances about the younger crowd members.

“They’re all the way at the front of a rock show and they don’t keep their arms up. They’re not looking behind them and have their phones up so when a surfer comes by of course they get kicked in the head!”

“They’re straight up just letting people fall, not everyone makes it all the way to the front.”

The conversation continued into the topic of concert etiquette, and it was around this point that I really began to feel the generational divide that the lineup of this night inevitably prompted. TX2 and Arankai brought most of the younger teens and early 20s crowd, while Catch Your Breath and Colorblind brought most of the 30 and 40-somethings. In the pit, these two groups collided. Perhaps the idea was to expand the fan bases of each band across different ages, but in result it created a conflicting atmosphere in the pit between two groups with different goals. The youngins wanted to take in the performance and record, the elders wanted to mosh and surf. In the end, I do think both groups succeeded in their intentions - albeit with a little friction from the other side.

CATCH YOUR BREATH

When Catch Your Breath took to the stage, any negative energy that had brewed seemed to completely disappear as the audience erupted into cheer and crowd surfing reached its peak. I must have seen at least 100 bodies lifted up in the air that night, often two or three hovering about the crowd at the same time, sometimes clashing into each other. The members of Catch Your Breath were a sharp contrast to the band that had previously held the stage - dressed maturely in all black; long sleeves, turtlenecks, and plain leather jackets. They carried a certain air of coolness that was paced and collected, yet effortless.

Josh Mowery’s screams, roaring and commanding, were excellently accompanied by bassist Cianan Madigan, guitarist Teddy Herrera, and the deafening sounds of the singing crowd. There were parts where the audience was so loud, I couldn’t hear the singing from the stage, especially during “21 Gun Salute”, one of the band’s biggest hits from their debut album, Shame On Me. I saw fans standing in the crowd - even some surfing -  with their hands aimed stiff to their foreheads in military salute, hollering their hearts out to the lyrics of this song. The band incited more of this energy throughout their whole set.

“Split this motherf*cker in half right now… Faster! Bigger!”

“Come on New York show me what the f*ck you got”

And the crowd obeyed happily every time, sweating and out of breath.

The room lulled momentarily two thirds into the set during the band’s only ballad of the night, “Good in Goodbye”. Crowd surfers took a break while couples held each other and swayed back and forth. I saw a mom in the back carrying her sleepy child in comically large noise-cancelling headphones while singing the words to herself. Mowery delivered a solid vocal performance. Airy and lusciously reverb-y, he brought the crowd to a sentimental brief moment before ramping it back up with “Y.S.K.W.” Just like that, the crowd surfers returned in full force.

Catch Your Breath songs are, loyal to the name, quite vocally exhausting, resulting in Mowery’s vocal performance slightly dwindling during the last few songs of the night. This is where the booming volume of the audience came in hand, as they filled the room competently any time Mowery pointed his mic into the crowd, and especially so at the track that ended the night with a bang - “Dial Tone”. The audience was rewarded with the knowledge that they were the loudest and rowdiest stop in the tour so far. Normally I would think that when a band says this, they're probably just empty platitudes to please the crowd. This time, however, I believe them.

CATCH YOUR BREATH | WEBSITE | INSTAGRAM | FACEBOOK | YOUTUBE


Check out more from our contributor:

SIMONE CUEVAS | WEBSITE | INSTAGRAM

Next
Next

You’re Not Alone: Saosin Celebrates Twenty Years of Self-Titled